About Us

Welcome to The Pie Proper, where every pie is crafted with love and the finest ingredients. Located in Highlands, TX, we specialize in creating delicious, homemade pies that bring comfort and joy to every occasion. From classic fruit pies to rich, indulgent cream pies and savory favorites, we believe a great pie has the power to bring people together.

I'm Sarah Tittel, the owner and baker behind The Pie Proper. My passion for baking started in my own kitchen, where I learned that the best pies are made with quality ingredients, a little patience, and a lot of heart. Whether you're looking for the perfect dessert for a family gathering, a sweet treat for yourself, or a savory pie for dinner, we've got you covered.

Our Promise:

• Quality Ingredients: We use only the freshest, highest-quality ingredients in every pie we make.

• Homemade Goodness: Every pie is made from scratch, just like Grandma used to make.

• Baked with Love: We put our heart into every pie, because we believe food tastes better when it's made with care.

Thank you for supporting The Pie Proper. We can't wait to share our pies with you!